Skip to Content

Oyster Bay by Sherwin Williams | Paint Color Review

Sharing is caring!

Last Updated on September 5, 2024 by lindseymahoney

If you’re looking for a timeless green paint color, Oyster Bay Sherwin Williams may be just what you need. 

Oyster Bay Sherwin Williams Color Review | Building Bluebird

This muted, cool green color is versatile and can be used in a variety of ways to create a classic and sophisticated look in your home. 

Oyster Bay Sherwin Williams | Color Review

Learn more about this popular, neutral paint color and get tips on how to incorporate it into your decor.

What color is Oyster Bay by Sherwin Williams?

SW Oyster Bay is a striking grayish-green color with slate blue undertones. It is included in the Recharge color palette of Sherwin William’s Living Well Collection. 

Oyster Bay Sherwin Williams Color Review | Building Bluebird

Sherwin Williams describes the colors included in the Recharge collection as filling the soul with calm and optimism. This timeless color brings to mind restful retreats, peaceful pools, and total relaxation.

Oyster Bay Sherwin Williams Color Review | Building Bluebird

It makes perfect sense that this neutral sage green is a popular choice for bedrooms and bathrooms.

I am always drawn to slightly desaturated, muddy colors like Oyster Bay. It is a great way to add warmth and richness to a space without overpowering it.

Oyster Bay Light Reflectance Value (LRV)

The LRV of Oyster Bay is 44. 

What is LRV anyway? It tells us how much light a color absorbs on a scale from 0 to 100. The lower the number, the less light the color will reflect and will therefore feel darker. 

The higher the LRV number, the more reflective the color, making a space feel lighter and brighter.

It is helpful to know the LRV because it can give you an idea of how dark or light the color will look in each specific room. 

For example, if you want to brighten up a room that doesn’t have a lot of natural sunlight (northern and western-facing rooms), Oyster Bay may be darker than you want. 

You can also ask the paint store to lighten the color – usually by increments of 25%. 

Whenever you choose a paint color it is important to add a few samples on the wall. I believe it is even more important to look at wall samples of paint colors that have an LRV lower than 50 to see how it looks with the light in that room.

What are the undertones of Oyster Bay?

A paint undertone is a color you don’t see that can cause the main color (tone) to feel warm or cool. 

Warm paint colors have yellow, beige, or pink undertones. Cool paint colors have green, purple or blue undertones.

Sherwin-Williams Oyster Bay has slate-blue undertones.

Is Oyster Bay considered a warm or cool color?

Oyster Bay Sherwin Williams Color Review | Building Bluebird

In general, green is considered a cooler color. The gray and faint blue undertones keep Oyster Bay on the cool side of the color wheel.

Although it is technically considered a cool color, it definitely does not feel cold and stark! 

The desaturation gives this green an earthy feel that makes a room feel warm and cozy.

What paint colors are similar to Oyster Bay?

Oyster Bay Sherwin Williams Paint Color Review

If you like Oyster Bay SW but prefer to use a different paint brand or slightly different shade of green, here are some similar colors:

What colors pair well with Oyster Bay?

Oyster Bay pairs well with crisp white trim (like Sherwin Williams Extra White) and can be accented with pops of color in accessories like throw pillows or curtains. 

Another way to use Oyster Bay is by painting kitchen cabinets or bathroom vanities for a fresh and updated look. 

Earth tones like warm wood accents and pops of black and warm gold are beautiful against Oyster Bay as the backdrop. 

The possibilities are endless with this classic and sophisticated shade.

What are some coordinating colors to pair with Oyster Bay Sherwin Williams?

Sherwin Williams Oyster Bay color review - coordinating color palette
Sherwin Williams Oyster Bay Color Palette

Oyster Bay Sherwin Williams is a versatile color that pairs well with a variety of complementary shades. 

For a classic and sophisticated look, pair it with crisp white trim and accents in shades of navy blue or charcoal gray. 

For a more playful and colorful look, pair it with bright pops of coral or yellow. 

To create a calming and serene atmosphere, pair it with soft shades of lavender or pale blue. 

The key is to choose complementary colors that enhance the beauty and elegance of Oyster Bay without overwhelming it.

Where can I use Oyster Bay in my home?

Oyster Bay can be incorporated into most design styles. It is a very popular color for bedrooms and power rooms, but it looks great in every room of the house.

Let’s check out a few examples of Oyster Bay throughout the home!

Design Style

Oyster Bay pairs beautifully with traditional designs, such as classic coastal style or farmhouse, as well as more modern styles, such as Scandinavian or minimalist designs.

Living Room or Dining Room

Oyster Bay Sherwin Williams Paint Color Review
Source | Sherwin Williams

Oyster Bay adds so much character to the main living space of a home. Paint your walls with this earthy green for the perfect cozy backdrop for everyday life.

Bathrooms

Oyster Bay Sherwin Williams Color Review | Building Bluebird

The first time I saw this earthy green tone was in my brother’s half bathroom in his 1920s colonial-style home

Oyster Bay was the perfect paint color for this tiny little bathroom! The ornate gold frame around the mirror pairs well with the gray green wall paint.

Oyster Bay Sherwin Williams Color Review | Building Bluebird

We completely renovated the second bathroom at our Toledo flip house and after choosing white tiles and a white vanity, I knew Oyster Bay was a great choice for the wall color. 

It definitely brought some life into the neutral new bathroom design.

Cabinetry

Oyster Bay Sherwin Williams Color Review | Building Bluebird
Source | Living Letter Home

Carmen from Living Letter Home painted her laundry room cabinets using Oyster Bay and it looks dreamy with the black accents and scalloped backsplash!


Whether you prefer a bold and colorful look or a more understated style, Oyster Bay Sherwin Williams is a great choice to consider for your home! I hope you found this paint color review helpful and inspiring as you turn your house into a home.

Happy Painting!

More Content You Will Love